这篇文章实在是与我心有戚戚焉。
我说胡兰成是因为他的书卖得好,尤其作为一个汉奸,竟然成了小资们心中的文化偶像,大有开篇不说胡兰成,纵读诗书也枉然的势头。我也不是那种看不得别人好 的人,假若胡兰成的文章真很牛逼,我也会老老实实地崇拜。可是读了《今生今世》,我鸡皮疙瘩掉了一地,掩卷犹叹,大丈夫不可以不肉麻啊?!
我不明白胡兰成的汉语为什么就那么点词汇量,形容谁都是“春风牡丹”,说什么都要扯上“人世岁月”,见到鸡狗也要慨叹“民国风物”,好像不把一点鸡毛蒜皮 的小事宏观化一下就会死,更何况宏观得很牵强。那文笔也不伦不类,然而竟让小资们一致叫好,原因只能是这厮泡妞很成功,因此男的艳羡,女的憧憬。
《今生今世》就是一本彻头彻尾的泡妞史,谁要举这书谈文学和文化,我跟谁急。他泡的妞中,有一个大名鼎鼎的张爱玲,许多人就是冲着她去读胡兰成的。这张爱 玲本就是个肉麻兮兮的人,整日价就是顾影自怜地装清高。我一向认为她的小说层次跟琼瑶差不了多少,除了男女那点破事就好像没有题材,当然有一帮油头粉面的 人仰慕她,比如傅雷。所以一旦她喜滋滋地成了胡兰成碗中的方便面,我一点也不奇怪。这两人是怎么勾搭上的,完全不重要。关键是他们在肉麻兮兮这点上,就志 同道合,是一对天生的璧人。
张爱玲的文章虽然烂,好歹比胡还是强点,可是以文章来比附男女关系,那就迂腐了。胡兰成的甜腻和肉麻才是她最需要的,她被麻翻了,又被踢开了,这不能赖 谁,因为她本来就好这口。我现在明白另一个特大汉奸周作人的书没他卖得火的原因了,因为周作人不会泡妞,只一辈子死守着个日本老婆,怎么能适应我们这个诲 淫诲盗的时代呢?
当然,胡兰成那点汉奸事,老提也没什么意思。他又不是蒋委员长,没有死节的义务。至于他不文不白的破文章,可以好好批判批判,我今天就算抛砖引玉了。
> kästner Says:
Warning: Undefined variable $comment in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_approved" on null in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
4 1 月, 2008 at 下午6:59
新年好 kevin :em02:
关于胡兰成,我的看法是:嬉笑怒骂皆文章。
写文章,可以是真情实感,可以是任务差事(比如工作报告,公文信函之类),自然也可以顾左右而言他者。
我记得小学老师对我们说过:文如其人(还有类似的 字如其人,画如其人……),不过这仅仅是建立在求真的基础上。但如果你还有印象的话,小学中学的作文,大多是骗人的,编造情节,无论如何也很少是真情实感。胡兰成不过是用一种真实的态度写一种不真实的事罢了。
换言之,或许你看不惯的胡兰成,并不是胡兰成本人;亦或者确是胡兰成本人,但他的这一面让人不喜欢。
人都是很复杂的动物。
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
> kästner Says:
Warning: Undefined variable $comment in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_approved" on null in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
4 1 月, 2008 at 下午9:32
张很有文才啊,当然我觉得很多人喜欢张并不是因为她有文才,而是因为读张就能把自己定位成某一类人。
曾经听说过古龙的书迷不屑金庸的书迷。让我相信:不止文人相轻,就连文人的读者也相轻。 :em06:
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
> 苏小旗 Says:
Warning: Undefined variable $comment in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_approved" on null in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
7 1 月, 2008 at 下午3:26
我也看不下去张爱玲,也许是她身上个性与气质太浓厚了,以致于我无法进入.
对于胡兰成我倒没怎么反感.
倒是这位老兄,不知道自己文采如何,批判人倒是话不少.
我想不管胡兰成怎样,张爱玲怎样,像他说的再假再装清高,也不至于要辛辛苦苦装一辈子.只是人活的方式和类型不同.你总不能说你爱吃大米饭,就说人家爱吃西餐的人是装的吧?
这人说得不好.
还不如你直接所表达的你的看法说得明白.
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
> 小冬 Says:
Warning: Undefined variable $comment in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_approved" on null in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
7 1 月, 2008 at 下午3:45
我还是很喜欢张的文章的
读来都有一股悲凉的感觉!
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
> 水瓶座 Says:
Warning: Undefined variable $comment in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_approved" on null in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 29
26 12 月, 2008 at 下午2:32
高中有一段时间挺迷张的,可能是因为她出名吧,但是在她的小说中找不到共鸣,可能本人比较俗吧,比较喜欢简单快乐或者积极向上的小说。
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 252
Warning: Attempt to read property "user_level" on bool in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-includes/deprecated.php on line 253
Warning: Undefined variable $oddcomment in /www/wwwroot/wordpress/wp-content/themes/OtherSide/comments.php on line 86